skip to main content

Naomi Campbell vs The Charity Commission: The limits of trustee responsibility

16th Nov 2026 | Charities & Not-for-Profits
Fashion pic of woman on catwalk
Trainee solicitor, Beth McSorley
Written by Beth McSorley
0191 211 7801
[email protected]

In 2024, Naomi Campbell was disqualified from acting as a charity trustee for five years, following a Charity Commission inquiry into her charity, Fashion for Relief. On October 1st 2026, the first-tier tribunal allowed Naomi Campbell’s appeal. The interesting question for trustees is not whether or not Naomi Campbell has been ‘cleared’, it is how this decision sits alongside the principle that trustees must act collectively.

In this article, trainee solicitor Beth McSorley explains the importance of building robust governance systems that prevent potential deception by trustees.

The Fashion for Relief story up to now

In 2021, The Charity Commission conducted a compliance visit into Fashion for Relief. The visit escalated into a statutory enquiry, where the Commission revealed serious misconduct and mismanagement of the charity. In September 2024, Naomi Campbell, Bianka Hellmich and Veronica Chou were disqualified from acting as trustees for 5 years, 9 years and 4 years, respectively. Campbell appealed the decision.

In October 2026, the first-tier tribunal allowed Naomi Campbell’s appeal, and the disqualification order was quashed. 

The decision was made on the basis that, although serious misconduct and mismanagement in the administration of Fashion for Relief had occurred, the most serious wrongdoing had been concealed from Campbell. 

Campbell’s co-trustee, Hellmich, had gone to the lengths of forging documents, using a false email address, deceiving professional advisors so as to issue unauthorised payments to herself and fraudulently misusing charity funds. The Tribunal held that Campbell could not have reasonably suspected Hellmich’s dishonesty at the point of wrongdoing. 

The judgement maintains that Campbell shared responsibility for Fashion for Relief, but that this was limited in this case to keeping proper minutes and completing the appropriate filings. The deception by Hellmich meant that the statutory criteria for Campbell’s disqualification were not met, and Campbell couldn’t be held to be unfit to act as a trustee. 

Collective responsibility 

According to Charity Commission guidance, trustees must act collectively and remain jointly responsible for any decisions made. A significant part of a trustee's role is to think for themselves and independently verify information, rather than simply deferring to co-trustees.

The original 2024 decision sparked a strong response from trustees and charity lawyers. In essence, the decision reinforced the established rule that every trustee shares equal, joint, legal accountability for the board's decisions. The fact that Hellmich had some legal knowledge didn't mean that Campbell could delegate her responsibility as a trustee entirely. Somewhere down the line, Fashion for Relief had failed in its management and, as a result, all of the trustees had been punished. The message to trustees was strong: every trustee is responsible and accountable for the oversight of a charity. 

So, what happens now that Campbell's appeal was allowed? The decision raises questions as to whether a trustee can ever reasonably rely on another trustee's expertise, and whether trustees who fail to enquire into other trustees' decisions can be protected from the principle of collective responsibility.  

Key takeaways 

Trustees aren't expected to be an expert in every area a charity may encounter. After all, the Charity Commission highlights that a key aspect of a trustee's role is knowing when, how and to what extent to delegate authority to a committee or a trustee to deliver the best outcome for the charity. 

However, it’s important for charities to understand the difference between placing reasonable reliance on other trustees (or committees) to undertake certain actions on behalf of the board and a complete disregard for overseeing those actions. So, when it comes to delegating authority to others on the board, how much oversight is enough? 

The tribunal focussed on the distinction between allowing another trustee absolute decision-making powers due to a reluctance to intervene and relying on a trustee with legal experience who committed sophisticated fraud and intended to deceive the board. It was noted that once Campbell was put on notice of the deceptive acts, she made reasonable enquiries. This decision therefore serves as a warning to trustees that the tribunal will look at what the trustee should have reasonably known and also what enquiries they should have made.

The practical lesson for charities is that good governance cannot rely on honesty. Governance controls should be in place to make dishonesty harder and more detectable. Our simple top tips for building governance systems to prevent deception are:

  1. Keep proper minutes which are sufficiently detailed for important decisions: The Fashion for Relief inquiry was hindered by poor record-keeping. Keeping proper minutes can help protect your position as a trustee.
  2. If something seems unusual or inconsistent with the charity's interests, ask questions. Investigating and questioning decision-making is part of a trustee's role. 
  3. Ensure the board has access to financial systems. Concentrating responsibility in a single trustee with no segregation of duties dilutes the control of the board and the reliance they can place on information made available to them. A trustee cannot make effective enquiries without having access to reliable information.
  4. Ensure there is regular financial reporting to the board that is full and transparent. 
     

The case of Campbell, therefore, doesn't dilute the obligation on a trustee to be ultimately responsible for the management and administration of their charity, but it reminds trustees of the potentially disastrous implications of not being proactive in their duties and of failing to build sufficiently robust governance structures to combat potential dishonesty. 

For more information please contact Beth McSorley at [email protected] or on 0191 211 7809.

Share this story...